Snape Survey, Snapeity, Dumbledore's sacrifice.
Adriana
glykonix at yahoo.com
Wed Mar 8 16:27:10 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 149280
Almost everything pertinent on this topic has already been stated and
restated on both sides of the argument.
I am one of those who believe Snape is DDM, but I will admit that some
of the arguments against him made me think (and almost made me doubt
him).
But I have one more point in favor of Snape that I don't believe to
have seen posted here. There has been much talk about Dumbledore
repeatedly saying he trusts Snape. Some saying that it was only so
that he could convince himself or because he was actually doubting it.
Now DD may have told lies and may have hidden truths, but I don't
believe he lies to himself.
And he is not the only one who says he trusts Snape with a reason. In
the scene where Harry tells DD that he overheard Snape and Malfoy
talking. DD restates his trust in Snape. And the snide voice of
Phineas Nigellus who was pretending to be asleep says 'I should think
not.'
And if Phineas says this, I will trust him, because that painting must
have seen a lot. It is clear that there is a firm reason for which DD
trust Snape completely.
Glykonix
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive