a bit of SHIP Ron/Hermione/Hermione must be stopped

Patricia Hurley patriciah711 at yahoo.com
Wed Mar 8 17:02:48 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 149285

Alla wrote:

> And I think her attacking Ron with birds was appaling too. It is
> funny, I think JKR commented that Ron had to make himself worthy of
> Hermione in HBP. Personally, I happen to think that Hermione was not
> doing worthy things at all in that book. Ron did not make her any
> promises, they are just sixteen and going and assaulting him because
> she was jealous, IMO, well it was not nice at all.

kchuplis:

> I think it is funny that of all the things to pick on Hermione 
> about, people choose the bird incident and (so far) people are 
> universally appalled. I feel like I am the only person who ever 
> suffered from intense jealousy. I'm not saying it is right, but 
> dang, if *I'd* had her ability and a wand at a few certain moments 
> in my life....well, bird attacks would probably been the least of 
> someone's worries!


Patricia:
Because this board is made of adults you may all be forgetting what 
it's like to be a 16 year old girl. I'm 18 and remember very well 
what life was like two years ago. In the world of teenagers, Ron 
and Hermione had an understanding that pretty much labels them "a 
couple". You notice that Lavender looks sulky a few times when 
Hermione comes around, before Ron and Lav hook up. Hermione and Ron 
both *knew* what they were to each other. Lavender even knew. It's 
not like Hermione caused Ron serious injury. She just let him know 
that she saw what was going on and that it was not okay. 

Another thing to remember before saying that Hermione is over-
judgmental and takes things into her own hands too often, is that 
this is war. This is life or death. This isn't a typical high school 
life, she is saving people and trying to keep people who are less 
than helpful out of the way. All is fair in Love and War. Hermione 
is good in my book.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive