Hermione must be stopped, or at least slapped

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Wed Mar 8 21:29:25 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 149287

Allie wrote:
> 
> I'm not convinced that the spots are totally gone, because they need 
> to be hidden under layers of makeup.  I was a little bit disturbed 
> that they were still there as well, until I realized that Marietta 
> NEVER APOLOGIZED to anyone.  To Harry, Hermione, or even her friend 
> Cho, who also could have been expelled!  Cho even defends her to
Harry at the end of OoTP!  And I'm thoroughly convinced that if
Marietta went to Hermione, apologized for almost getting them all
expelled, and asked Hermione to remove the charm, she would do it in a
heartbeat.  
<snip>

Carol responds:
But Marietta was Obliviated by Kingsley Shacklebolt in DD's office.
Isn't it possible that she doesn't remember going to Umbridge at all,
or even attending the meetings or signing the parchment, in which case
she wouldn't even understand why the spots are there?

I'm a bit disappointed in Madam Pomfrey's abilities, BTW. She can
shrink overgrown teeth and fix broken noses with a wandflick, but she
can't cure a case of renegade acne? Surely some staff member besides
Snape can invent a countercurse, especially if Hermione were to tell
them the hex she used. And if St. Mungo's can cure "spattergroit"
(sp?), why not SNEAK"?

Carol, not quite sure that Hermione can counter her own jinx or that
she would do so if asked











More information about the HPforGrownups archive