Interesting throwaway on Hermione at JKR's updated site (dragon's blood)
cubfanbudwoman
susiequsie23 at sbcglobal.net
Fri Mar 10 16:37:55 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 149375
SSSusan:
> "...and Hermione Granger (cleverest girl in the year and the only
> person in the class to know all the uses of dragon's blood)."
PJ responded:
> I didn't expect only Dumbledore to know the 12 uses because, like
> any other invention, it needs to be known by many people who can
> put those discoveries to good use. Otherwise what's the sense of
> spending all that time working on the problem? And Dumbledore
> likes people to know just how smart he is.
> :)
SSSusan:
Oh, yes, I didn't mean to imply that I meant literally *no* one
besides DD knew them. I figured since that bit was on the back of
his wizard card, he was well known for having discovered the 12
uses. Thus, I assumed many adult wizards did know about them from
reading/study.
What I didn't realize was that any of the kids among "our" main
characters also knew all 12. They've been mentioned enough in the
series -- dragon blood has been mentioned enough in the series --
that I've always thought it would be coming back in somehow, some
way. But I guess in my mind I envisioned Hermione *discovering* the
full list at some opportune moment which -- since she's not said
anything about it yet that I can recall -- I recently assumed would
be in Book 7.
Now that I find she's known the 12 uses all along, well, that kinda
shoots that theory out the window.
PJ:
> What surprised me was that it didn't say the only *student* in the
> class to know, but the only *person*. Is this said differently in
> the UK than in the US or does this mean teachers as well as
> students? If so, I wonder who's class she was in and how many
> teachers are still ignorant of the uses?
SSSusan:
PJ, I think you're assuming "class" to mean "classroom" or one
specific subject. I took "class" to mean their *year.* That is,
since the synopsis was of PS/SS, I think JKR meant that Hermione was
the only person in Harry's year -- among the 1st years -- who knew
them all.
Siriusly Snapey Susan, who didn't even type her name correctly in her
last post. :-|
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive