Tonks' role/ WAS:Lupin and The Marauders

[susanbones2003]

No: HPFGUIDX 149476

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "mrsfigg1968" <angirussell at ...> 
wrote:
Snipped
> Angirussell writes:
> 
SNIPPED again
 
> Lupin is just a classic tragic figure.  His redemption may be in 
Tonks,
> but I always liked the idea that Tonks is the traitor in the midst..I
> don't know why.
> 
> Angirussel

Jen D. here, posing more questions than she ever answers, hoping 
someone might be troubled by the same things...

I don't want to suspect Tonks but the day she discovered Harry 
partially covered by the cloak, looking for the ROR, it just bothers 
me. She made absolutely no sense. If she were looking for DD, why 
would she be on the 7th floor, far away from DD's tower? Seeing things 
through Harry's eyes is such a deceptive way to look at things so we 
are lulled into thinking she's perhaps grieving over Sirius (surface-y 
type of misdirection)which we can get past with a little thought but 
there is still the bigger thing of "looking for DD." It doesn't add 
up. DD doesn't wander the hallways. And she's supposed to be on guard 
duty. Not wandering the halls herself. So, while I am not prepared to 
embrace a spyTonks, I do have a concern over her. I bet you thought 
this thread was through! No, just morphed.
Jen D.
>