Snape rides again

[whtwitch91]

No: HPFGUIDX 149604

Olivier said:
<My evidence? Thin, admittedly, but DD does say"Please don't hurt them 
please, hurt me instead" and then screams "Kill me" when drinking the 
green potion.>



Finally, a logical explaination for those strange statements.  DD, who 
depises divination, has a premonition of his own.  It make the whole 
thing work together.  Snape and DD use legilmens ability on the tower 
to come to an agreement and Snape acts.  I do agree with the previous 
listees who beliexeve that DD and Snape had discussed this possiblity 
previously so it does not come as a surprise to Snape, but I used to 
thnk that this tower scene had been previously set up, and now it 
seems that it was an improvised moment. I think DD and Snape have 
always had a rough plan in their minds about how things might work 
out, and that the plan may include DD's death.

I can't buy sweet-natured vegetarian Snape, he's a compl
ex, deep and abrasive person, but I do believe in DDM Snape.  Nothing 
else makes any kind of sense.

Sue, suffering with typing problems on her new laptop