DDMSnape (was Re: LID!Snape rides again (was: High Noon for OFH!Snape))

[OctobersChild48 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 149877



Carol:
> As for DDM!Snape killing DD, killing DD, you know the arguments 
> and I'm not going to repeat them except to say that there was no 
> saving DD from the DEs if Snape or the poison didn't kill him, 
> and both Draco and Harry would almost certaingly have died with 
> DD and Snape if Snape had allowed the UV to kill him. Only Snape 
> could get Harry safely off the tower and the DEs and Draco off 
> the Hogwarts grounds. (The arguments and evidence for this idea 
> have already been presented by many people in many threads. 
> Anyone who does a search can find them.)
 

Okay, I'm getting ready to throw in the towel and cry uncle. From 
the beginning of the series I have hated Snape and considered him 
a mean, nasty, evil person. After reading HBP I was thoroughly 
convinced of what this list calls ESESnape. As I have been reading 
all of the theories put forth on this list I have been finding 
myself leaning more and more towards DDMSnape and this statement 
makes more sense than anything or any theory I have read. It's not 
that I really want to believe it, it makes it so much harder to 
hate Snape, but it's the only thing that makes sense. 

Sandy