DDM!Snape & the UV

richter_kuymal richter at ridgenet.net
Tue Mar 21 14:02:23 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 149878

SSSusan: Not sure I'm following this bit about Fenrir.  What makes 
you think he's a Muggle?  Would Voldy bring *any* Muggle into 
alliance with  him??

PAR: Because he is described as NOT having a wand -- he tries to 
attack DD with hands and teeth.  As for why LV would deal with him --
 he is the acknowledged leader of the werewolves.  Why would LV 
promote being pureblood when he himself isn't?  Becasue LV doesn't 
really care about muggles OR if wizards are pureblood, halfblood or 
muggle-born.  He hates them all.  He just spouts the mantra that 
gets him the allies he wants.

SSSusan: As for this "minor" task facing Snape of handling Draco, 
Fenrir &  two ostensibly "lesser" DEs... um... let's just think 
about how long  it takes to cast a spell. Snape would have to freeze 
*two* people, which would mean casting *two* separate spells, 

PAR:it takes the time to say (or think) a word.   DD manages to take 
on multiple opponents in the headmaster's office in OOP (where he 
takes out Fudge and Aurors but doesn't harm Harry, Marietta or 
McDonagall), and this is where they are watching DD.  Snape, 
the "great warrior" can't do it with the element of surprise?  The 
DEs would have to recognize they were being attacked by Snape (hard 
to do if he uses a nonverbal attack) TURN and confront him (they are 
covering DD) and he can't manage this?  The whole idea of Snape 
being good enough at battle that he needs to be kept alive to help 
Harry rather falls apart if he is only good enough to take out one 
opponent at a time.  
--- PAR










More information about the HPforGrownups archive