Why wasn't Harry sent to either a lightsided wizarding family or a muggle family?
Jutika Gehani
mail_to_jutika at yahoo.com
Tue Mar 28 05:00:28 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 150181
Jutika previously:
> As far as living with the Dursleys' is concerned, that was the
> only way Dumbledore could assure that Lily's sacrifice would act
> as his protection. If Petunia would have refused to take Harry in,
> the charm wouldn't have been sealed, leaving Harry unprotected.
John wrote:
> Harry's love for others was what drove off Voldemort from possessing
> him and IMO is what prevented Quirrel from touching him, not the blood
> wards.
Jutika:
Heres how I analyze the whole thing.....
Harry's ability to love protects him from Voldemort. But IMO this protection comes from the blood ward itself. Even Ron and Hermione have lived with loving families and even they have the ability to love (sometimes even more than Harry's ability..), but they still are not protected by that ability.
On the other hand, Lily's sacrifice (i.e. her love for Harry) is what Dumbledore keeps referring to as old magic which Voldemort can never understand....
Just IMO....
Jutika.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive