Blood & predjudice...or what makes for strange bedfellows? (Long....)
sugaranddixie1
sugaranddixie1 at yahoo.com
Fri Mar 31 16:39:45 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 150336
Starting with LV- the head of the organization. Acceptable to his
followers because he renounced his father? Seems ironic to think of
Lucius Malfoy in a organization headed by a half-muggle. It presents
a problem for me because being from the southern U.S., the closest
analogy I conjure up is a man who's half-black heading the Klu Klux
Klan. In other words, denial of parentage wouldn't solve the blood
problem for the other members of the organization- the predjudice
would still exist & saying "I renounce my Dad" doesn't change the
facts... (I seem to remember reading somewhere that Hitler had some
Jewish blood in him so perhaps there's some sort of historical
precedent for the storyline there.)
Now on to Snape- also of mixed parentage. Accepted as a Death-eater
& highly-thought of/friends with the Malfoys. Again, why would
Lucius Malfoy deign to fraternize with a non-pureblood when it seems
to be such a huge issue for him? Is he not aware of Snape's
lineage? Is Draco not aware of it? It seems like it would be the
first thing the Malfoy family would want to ascertain before letting
someone into their circle.... When it comes to LV and Snape that
doesn't pose as much of a problem to me...their mixed-parentage would
be a grounds on which they could really relate. I do think Snape had
mixed feelings ( at least during his teen years) about his own
lineage- he never defaced the words "..Half-Blood Prince..." in the
textbook- left them there for posterity. Yet he called Lily
a "..Mudblood..." when she came to his aid in OOP.
So my point is this- How can the Malfoys profess to be so obsessed
with people's bloodlines & still do the things they do? The ultimate
irony? The irrationality of prejudice? So few pure-bloods left that
they'd be sitting home alone if they didn't bend the rules a bit?
Any thoughts?
E.T.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive