Snape's memory
Wade Caroline
wdcaroline at yahoo.ca
Wed May 3 17:25:32 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 151851
I have a question:
In OOP when HP retrieves Snape's memory of being tormented by James Potter, I wondered at the time if Snape's memory of that torment and what ACTUALLY happened would be the same. I thought JKR would be reveal later that Snape's memory was not exactly what happened, thus keeping James' image intact. Even after Sirius and Lupin admited that they were, in fact, jerks, (only teenagers after all) I remained unconvinced, because it seems to me that one's memory of what happened when one is being bullied would become embellished over the years.
Am i wrong?
wc
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive