SHIP Ginny's love life (was Harry/Ginny)
quigonginger
quigonginger at yahoo.com
Sat May 6 09:25:02 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 151908
Yahoomort has been hungry today. Let's see if this posts. Unlike
people of higher intelligence :coughcarolcough:, I didn't save my
original and am doing a rerun from memory.
Betsy Hp said (re: Ron catching Ginny and Dean snogging):
> But I don't get the level of Ginny's anger. She was making out with
> a guy in a hallway. A corridor that is described as a "usual
> shortcut up to Gryffindor Tower". So it's not like she isn't aware
> that she's exposing herself to comment. Also, it's not like Ron has
> been policing Ginny. He didn't realize she was dating Michael
> Corner. And he didn't realize that she'd started dating Dean until
> she told him.
>
> If Ron had been dogging Dean and Ginny's every move, I could
> understand the level of rage Ginny flies into at this moment. But
> from what I've read, this is the first Ron says anything. And he's
> not really out of bounds. I can't see any big brother being happy
> with his sister making out in a public corridor. (Big sisters
> generally don't approve of such things either. <g>)
(major snippage all around)
Ginger:
Let's take a look at what we know of the Sex Life of Ginny Weasley and
How Her Brothers React.
PS- crush on Harry. Little girl crush. No reaction from brothers.
CoS- crush on Harry. Allegedly sent him a singing Valentine, which
F&G mocked.
Personally I think there was something with Tom Riddle, the very least
of which was that she was flattered by his attention and very naive as
to his intentions. It almost gets her killed. The 4 brothers at
Hogwarts are made very aware of how much they would miss her and wish
they could protect her. She gets a reputation with them as trusting
and vulnerable beyond that which is normal in brother/sister
realtionships.
PoA- gets about as much page time as Molly's dish water. Crush on
Harry assumed.
GoF- Goes to Yule Ball w/ Neville. Brothers don't react, but then,
wouldn't you trust your kid sister with Neville? I know I would.
Still actually crushing on Harry. Shows character by not breaking her
date with Neville. Meets Michael Corner, although we don't know about
it at that time.
OoP- Has been dating Michael in secert. Now we get to the juicy
stuff. After the Hog's Head (see the final pages of ch 16) meeting,
Ron finds out that Ginny has been dating Michael. First he gags on
his butterbeer and spills it down his front, then he asks which one
Michael was, after which he announces that he didn't like him. Upon
finding that Ginny no longer fancies Harry, he is "quivering with
indignation". He asks why she didn't tell him, and Hermione replies
that Ginny knew that he'd take it badly. Hermione asks him not to
harp on it. He says he will do no such thing, but continues "to
chunter under his breath all the way down the street".
When Ron finds out that she ditched Michael (ch 38), he is delighted.
He then hints that she find someone better, hinting at Harry. When
she says she has chosen Dean, Ron upends the chess board.
On to HBP- In ch 6, they are in F&G's shop. Ginny is looking at love
potions, but F&G won't sell one to her. They've heard she "has about
five boys on the go". She tells them that whatever they have heard
from Ron is a big fat lie.
I find this suspicious. How does she know they have heard it from
Ron? OK, he's at Hogwarts, so he's the obvious one. How does she
know that "whatever" they have heard is a big fat lie? Just from that
one sentance? How does she know that it is Ron doing the exaggerating
rather than F&G? This says "off-page conversations" to me.
She tries to change the subject, but they ask point blank if she is
going with Dean. She tells them that she is, but he is one boy, not
five. She again tries to change the subject, but they ask what about
Michael. She tells them she dumped him, and they ask if she's not
moving through boyfriends too fast. Hmm, two boyfriends from the
middle of her 3rd year (Yule Ball) to the beginning of her 5th year?
And they think it's "moving through boyfriends... too fast"? What has
Ron been telling them?
Ginny turns on Fred with a Molly-like glare and tells him it's none of
his business. She also tells Ron not to tell tales.
Why the glare? After only a couple of questions and a comment? I
think she is tired of hearing about it. This points a finger on Ron
to me. Only a few weeks have elapsed from the train in OoP, when he
finds out that she is seeing Dean, to her being sick of conversation
about him. My guess is that Ron's been harping.
On the train in the next chapter, Pansy mentions to Blaise that lots
of boys like Ginny, and that even he, Mr. Hard to Please, thinks she's
good looking. No reaction from brothers as they aren't there.
Now we hit ch. 14. The big blow-up. I think we've seen that Ron has
a history with Ginny where her love life is concerned. He didn't pay
much attention before Michael- he didn't even know they had broken up,
but now that she's with Dean, he's not only talking to her, but to F&G
as well. We've not seen any animosity between Ron and Dean in the
past that would account for his hostility, nor do we have any record
of him confronting Dean or demanding to know his intentions.
After Ginny sends Dean back to the common room, she turns on Ron and
says "let's get this straight once and for all. It is none of your
business who I go out with or what I do with them".
Ooh, "once and for all"? That's not something you say the first time
someone comments on something. That's pretty much up there with "for
the last time" or "I've told you a million times". It's none of his
business what she does with them? What has he been saying she has
done? He says in the corridor that he doesn't want people "thinking"
she's a... but in that conversation, he doesn't question what she is
actually doing. Did we miss a conversation outside of Harry's PoV
where he did ask what she had been doing with all those guys? It
could be.
Not much is said after her breakup with Dean, only that Ron and Harry
agree that she is too popular for her own good (ch24).
When she and Harry get together, Ron doesn't mind a bit, much to
Harry's surprise.
Whew. This is longer than my original. Back to your question: Where
did Ginny's anger come from? I speculate that this has been building
up, mostly off-page, but with enough hints on-page, that the incident
in ch. 14 was the straw that broke the camel's back.
Ginger, glad she doesn't have older brothers.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive