CHPDISC: HBP14, Felix Felicis

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Sun May 7 11:43:43 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 151949

 
> Angie replies:
> 
> Actually, I hadn't thought of that. It was also mentioned in the 
very 
> first chapter. It just seemed like foreshadowing for the last book, 
> which would apparently mean we can look forward to a lot more 
> Dementors (BTW, how long does it take them to become "adults?")

Potioncat:
The mist seems to be everywhere, but it doesn't seem to really do 
anything...yet. I'm just wondering if there's going to be an army of 
Dementors next book? and I wonder if we'll see Snape's method of 
dealing with them? 

Angie:
> Honestly, the first time I read this, I was shocked.  I couldn't 
help 
> but think of the Alfred Hitchcock movie.  I don't know why 
this "came 
> off" to me worse than any of the other spells that any of the 
> students have cast on each other (to this point in the story), but 
it 
> did. 

Potioncat:
Oh, me too. But first the birds reminded me of Disney's "Snow White" 
waiting for her prince to come. Quite a contrast.

Oops, by mistake I snipped Angie's part about Krum. Isn't he supposed 
to reappear. How will this "reminder" of him play into his 
appearance. Or was this it?

 
> Angie again:
> Nah, I actually had that one figured out.  Maybe the only thing in 
> the entire series, mind you.  If I was Hermione, I would work on 
> being a little less predictable.  Like Harry, I expected Hermione 
to 
> jump to the wrong conclusion, for Ron to think Harry had done it, 
and 
> therefore, to make it a self-fullfulling prophesy.

Potioncat:
I took this one hook line and sinker. I was expecting a good 
Harry/Snape confrontation when Snape discovered it, as I knew he 
would. I was actually shocked that Harry was doing such a thing. 

To my credit, I knew we were being tricked with Slughorn and the DADA 
position.








More information about the HPforGrownups archive