Calling Tonks Nymphadora, Snape's looks, etc.

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Fri May 12 02:17:43 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 152130

Tonks: 
> As to Tonks' and Snape's interaction when Harry is late getting off 
> the train. I just listened to that chapter on CD and Snape's use of 
> her name is nothing out of place, but his dig is at her Protronus 
> and the fact that it looks `weak'.  That is his way of saying that 
> he thinks that she is too good for Lupin. IMO.


Potioncat:
I think you have a very good point here. I certainly agree that the use 
of Nymphadora wasn't a dig. I know she tells Harry to call her Tonks 
and I know she doesn't like her name, but DD uses it and no one thinks 
he was trying to insult her.

But even better, I like your interpretation of the rest of the 
conversation. It sure would help to understand what the previous 
Patronus was and who it might have represented.








More information about the HPforGrownups archive