Snape could have?

[Tonks]

No: HPFGUIDX 152213

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, juli17 at ... wrote:
>
> Julie:
>  
> BTW, the more interesting question to me has always been why
> didn't Snape allow the DE to crucio Harry, or better yet why didn't
> Snape crucio Harry himself? If he's DDM the answer is obvious.
> If he's ESE or OFH, it's not so obvious. I doubt LV cares if Harry
> suffers a little pain, so long as he's not rendered insane. And 
> Snape hates Harry, with no deliberate exaggeration of that feeling
> required or likely if he's ESE or OFH. He has no reason *not* to 
> enjoy a bit of torture on the bane of his existence these past 
> six miserable years at Hogwarts. 
>  

Tonks:

Hummm
.  thinking again.. A scary and dangerous thing I know. ;-)

If someone Crucioed Harry, would LV feel it? Probably not, I think 
the scar connection only happens from LV to Harry, but maybe
?

Tonks_op