Why Lily could have saved herself

FriarTuck97 friartuck97 at yahoo.com
Wed May 17 13:14:31 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 152373

Goddlefrood <gav_fiji at yahoo.com> wrote:
I am firmly of the view that JKR would not have placed as much 
emphasis as she has on Lily's gifts as a potioneer unless they were 
to play an important role in book 7.

It is a part of the history of the wizarding world that Lily is 
deceased, but it has also been declared, by Voldemort himself, that 
Lily needn't have died.

There is a plausible explanation for this, which runs something like 
this:

Harry discovers that the reason Lily might have been spared was that 
she had discovered some powerful potion that no one (apart from 
perhaps Snape) is aware of and which has qualities that would finish 
off the evil that men do or strip a wizard of his powers perhaps.

Only she was capable of making it thus explaining why Voldemort was 
prepared to spare her life, but she refused to co-operate, as we 
know, and was, therefore, killed.

The secret potion then went with her to her grave.  <snip>

FT:
Goddlefrood, I must give it up...that is a wonderful word you have created..."Potioneer!"  I rather like that!
   
The problem with Potions is the sheer number of them; like spells, 
there are always new ones to be introduced to, so I agree that there 
will be something to her skills in Book 7.
   
One other thing about that night...
   
Hagrid makes a throwaway comment about seeing Sirius near the rubble 
of the Potter's house...perhaps the AK which bounced off Harry and 
knocked the hell out of LV kept rebounding until it destroyed the 
house...mere speculation, but I cannot follow "Potioneer..."  
   
Once again, great word!   
   
   
  -FT







More information about the HPforGrownups archive