Request for new topics

Tara Tierney lunasaproject at yahoo.co.uk
Thu May 18 21:10:23 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 152469

> Brady:
> 
> This is a welcome change :)
> 
> BTW, if Harry cn't see clearly with his glasses, why are we assuming 
> that the person he saw was Aberforth and not DD himself?? Why would 
> Dung be fumbling with something if it was not fear of DD?? Harry 
> thought he recognises him as the barman, but the distance and the 
> rain on his glasses can definitly make DD look like the barman, can't 
> they?
> 
> Just my tuppence.
> Brady.
>
Lunasa:
Maybe Dung is fumbling whatever he's holding in fear of Aberforth 
because he KNOWS Aberforth is Dumbledore's brother? Or wasn't Dung 
barred from the Hogshead? Perhaps he's fumbling in fear of Aberforth 
himself, maybe his barring was something more embarassing that was 
previously thought. And it would have to be something pretty 
embarassing or serious to get barred from a pub like the Hog's Head. Or 
maybe Aberforth is simply the angrier Dumbledore brother. 













More information about the HPforGrownups archive