Snape, Apologies, and Redemption--Lupin vs. DD

[Adriana]

No: HPFGUIDX 152614

Lanval said:
> And while we're talking Sirius and Snape, and compare accumulated 
> sins, we should remember that Snape really DID try to have Sirius  
> (and possibly Lupin!) killed at the end of POA -- worse, Kissed by 
a 
> Dementor -- without a trial, without listening to the evidence. 
Even 
> after he is told that Sirius is innocent, he throws a spittle-
flying 
> tantrum for not getting his way. And if Snape is DDM all the 
way... 
> what reason would he have to doubt Dumbledore? 
> 
> Lanval, who's torn between being supremely baffled and highly 
> amused, having read the recent Sexy!Snape posts...
>
Glykonix:
Yes you're right while we're talking Sirius and Snape why not bring 
up the end of POA. 
I clearly remember Black taking special care that Snape bump his 
lolling head on the low ceiling, while I also remember that when 
Snape regained consciousness, he conjured stretchers and lifted the 
limp forms of Harry, Hermione, and Black onto them. A fourth 
stretcher with Ron already floating at his side. And took them all 
to the castle.

And he did ask for a reason to kill him, not that he didn't have 
enough. Not that he would have been questioned if he killed Black, 
he would have been a hero. He was going to do the `right' thing at 
least from the MOM point of view. 
Black and Lupin didn't have these reservations when they were about 
to kill Peter. 

I still think it was extremely stupid of them not to wake Snape up, 
they could have tied him up and listen to the whole thing, I really 
don't think he would have been that irrational if he had actually 
known what had happened, and I'm sure Peter wouldn't have escaped
 
but of course if Peter hadn't escaped there wouldn't have been any 
Moldyvoldy return the next year.

And you might have been supremely baffled and highly amused, after 
having read the recent Sexy!Snape posts, but my inner Pansy has had 
a blast reading them.
 
Glykonix