Snape a mole all along? WAS: Re: Draco, Harry & Norbert

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 152786


> Lilygale here:
<SNIP>
>> Snape as "DDM all along" provides a very simple explanation for why 
> Dumbledore trusted him so completely.  
<SNIP>


Alla:

On the other hand, Snape as DD!M all along provides no explanation for 
Dumbledore telling Harry that Snape felt remorse after telling the 
prophecy to Voldemort. Except of course if Dumbledore lying through 
his teeth here, which I am not ready to accept yet. :)

In light of DD withholding the truth from Harry in PS/SS, but also 
telling him that I will not of course lie, I find Dumbledore as liar 
even more difficult to accept.

JMO,

Alla.