[HPforGrownups] Harry's death

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 153002

>   KJ writes:
> 
>     All of these posts were extremely interesting and, of course, 
> brought up very good points in their rebuttals. I would like to 
say that 
> I certainly do not advocate for or sympathize with juvenile 
suicide. As 
> former constable, involved in several, I see this as a prime 
example of 
> "doing what is easy, not what is right", as did Merope.
> 
>     I also find it interesting that Lily's sacrifice for Harry, 
DD's 
> sacrifice for the good of the WW , and the possibility of Snape's 
> eventual sacrifice to bring about the downfall of Voldemorte is 
regarded 
> with approval. I see no difference in Harry coming to the same 
> conclusion and making the same choice. In fact, I see these 
previous 
> plot lines all converging on this.


Alla:

I absolutely think that at some point Harry will make a choice to 
sacrifice himself in the book 7, where we diverge is that I think 
that at another point of plotline he will be saved somehow either 
from making the final sacrifice OR during such sacrifice. :)

Oh, and the way I look at Lily sacrifice and DD sacrifice is that 
they made it not just for the good of WW, but for Harry to live 
eventually. As DD said ( I think it will help you to survive - his 
lessons, etc - paraphrasing here).

That is why I am so very fond of "stopper of death" playing its role 
in book 7.

Alla,
who also so wants long and happy "life" for Harry and does disagree 
with your son that Harry is only useful as a weapon :)

Sorry.