Good and bad expression of house traits (Was Nice vs. Good)

houyhnhnm102 celizwh at intergate.com
Mon May 29 02:01:59 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 153051

a_svirn:

> This is a serious accusation to saddle the Hufflepuffs 
> with. And for  the life of me I don't see how it can 
> be the other side of the "fair  play" coin. Far from 
> "abdicating the responsibility for thinking for  oneself" 
> fairmindedness implies the ability and determination to 
> judge for oneself.

houyhnhnm:

I have been intrigued by Rowling's statement that the four houses
represent the four elements.  In astrology, each of the three signs
associated with a particular element has its negative and positive
expression, but no sign is superior to any other.

Rowling has shown us good and bad Gryffindors, and bad Slytherins. 
She has implied that there are good Slytherins and she has also
implied that no house is superior to any other.

So what would a "bad" Hufflepuff trait be if not conformity? (I should
have used the word "conformity" rather than "mediocrity".  It is
closer to what I was trying to say.)

What is a "bad" Ravenclaw like?  We know the virtues of the other two
houses.  What are their vices?

I am open to suggestions.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive