Minerva McGonagall Speculation

[Barb Roberts]

No: HPFGUIDX 153084

Recently, we had a few threads on ESE | Minerva. (Not that I can find 
them again--so many posts to wade through). This is an idea that I just 
don't see. Not that it's not interesting to speculate; however, I see 
Dumbledore trusting Minerva with his most the thing that may be most 
important to him--Hogwarts. So important is Hogwarts that he doesn't 
want her getting sidetracked with other things. I think she would find 
it difficult to not take over the Horcrux problem if she knew about it. 
I don't think it's lack of trust on Dumbledore's part that has him 
keeping MM separate from some of the activities, but rather DD method 
of keeping MM focused and securing the future of the school.

I have another thought, possibly as wild a theory, concerning Minerva 
though. It however hinges on the theory that Dumbledore is not dead.  
If Dumbledore is, in some way still present, it will be Minerva who 
discovers it. Why? It's her initials "MM."  it's the same initials as 
Mary Magdalene. And since McGonagall is at Hogwarts and has access to 
DD's office, if DD is around in anyway, I think she will be the one who 
makes this discovery.


Barbara
(Ivogun)