Prejudice and non-preudice in the WW
puduhepa98 at aol.com
puduhepa98 at aol.com
Wed May 31 00:54:35 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 153158
>Clare:
>Hmm, you don't know England then?
<The foreign is not really accepted well. We have courses on racism
<now because there are so many Middle Eastern families moving here
<and many inner city schools have more Pakistani and Indian children
<than English. As to American, the children accept that which is
,popular regardless of where it comes from but they are formed by
<their parents and regardless of rightness, political correctness or
<my own opinions (which are complex) England is extremely anti-
,America.
Nikkalmati:
You remind me of the scene in Bend it like Beckam where the coach explains
to the Pakistani girl, who has just been insulted by a racial slur, that he
knows what it is like to be discriminated against and ridiculed - because he
is Irish! That scene reminded me of a scene from a 40's movie (whose name I
have forgotten but I think it starred Errol Flynn) set in India where a
half-Indian officer in the British army moves into a dorm or house with other
officers. The others all move out, but one. When asked why he stayed, the
officer says "You see, I'm a half-breed too. My mother is Irish." <g>
To relate this to the Potterverse, have we all notice how there is no racial
tension among the students in the WW? We have the Patel twins (Indian
extraction) and I believe Lee Jordan is black (and of course Seamus is Irish!) ,
but despite other prejudices and house tensions as far as race or ethnicity
goes - nothing. JKR doesn't even make a point of showing us this harmony. It
just exists. In this regard the WW is an ideal society and I'm sure JKR
wants her readers to absorb this easy acceptance as a contrast to the prejudice
she also shows us. Thoughts?
Nikkalmati
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive