Horcrux hunting
whirledgirl
blink_883 at hotmail.com
Tue May 30 21:49:43 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 153161
Carol wrote:
<SNIP>
Whatever the case, I agree that destroying the other Horcruxes isn't
oing to be nearly as easy as stabbing a diary with a poisoned fang.
Distaiyi wrote:
Maybe it's just me, but "easy" doesn't seem an apt description of this
articular accomplishment.
WG* thinks:
That Carol may have meant spearing the diary with a poisoned fang is
relatively easier (or less arduous!) than finding out and learning
whatever spells or type of magic that Dumdledore obviously knew.
It seems that while many have speculated what the horcruxes are, even
where they are, few have thought about how exactly Harry will destroy
them. If you choose to believe it won't be Harry, then I guess this
is less relevant (as the character you might think this task will fall
to may be able to destroy them anyway, Snape, Aberforth, whoever).
How, then, is Harry, without any idea of where to start, meant to know
where to go first?
Also, as a possibility, I'd like to raise the issue that it is
possible DD has left Harry some papers, which may either be presented
to Harry by McGonagall as DD told Harry about Grimmauld place
belonging to him after Sirius died etc.
Does anyone else think JKR has shed loads of stuff to include in this
book?
Anyone thought if she'll carry on the (relatively) linear time she's
been keeping? Or maybe jump forwards a few years here and there?
In HBP, Harry does say (I'm sorry I can't find the chapter now, but
when the trio get their OWL results) that he still wants to become an
auror, even though it was Fake!Moody that gave him this idea, he
couldn't think of anything else he'd rather be, and that it would give
him the best chance of survival. This would put the 'final battle'
years perhaps from the time of HBP. Or, has it just not fully dawned
on Harry yet? Are we anticipating things a bit? Is it possible JKR will
have a - AND AFTER HARRY'S AUROR TRAINING - part?
Sorry for the deviation lol.
Thanks
WG*
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive