Horcrux hunting
whirledgirl
blink_883 at hotmail.com
Tue May 30 22:00:10 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 153163
Potioncat:
Many wizards can cast a Patronus. Only the Order uses them for
communication. Snape apparantly doesn't use them against Dementors.
So perhaps he could conceal his Patronus from the DEs. Of course,
it's still a theory that his Patronus will change. If it does, I'm
not sure how we'll know...
Lolita:
There might be 50 wizards with phoenix patronuses out there, as far
as we know. Or maybe I've forgotten the way that functions, in which
case, feel free to remind me :)).
<Snip>
WG*:
What about the difficulty Harry has mastering how to even cast a
patronus? I recall from what Lupin said that not every wizard can
cast a patronus. Heck, not even every wizard can cast proper shield
charms! Never mind ones (because in essence, isn't a patronus a
shield against Dementors?) that can or can't produce a decent
patronus in the presence of dementors! Has Snape even got a memory
happy enough to create a patronus? Enough love, which seems to be
the type of memory patronuses (patroni?) 'respond' to more?
I suggest that maybe Snape has not got a patronus, revealing he is
in fact not 'good', a real DE. This is why we haven't seen it, why
it would give him away.
Furthermore, there are two things throughout the series that stick
in my mind regarding Snape - 1) DD says (in PS I seem to recall) he
has a more brilliant mind, and that therefore his mistakes are
accordingly bigger and 2) Harry is a good judge of character. PS,
train journey. Rebuttal of Draco's 'friendship'. This is one of the
first things we find out about Harry's personality, his integral
character. The equivalent we have of DD, on the other hand, is him
leaving the Dursley's literally on their doorstep.
ohhhpppss this always happens- didn't mean to write so much heh!!
WG*
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive