Snape's Patronus (was Re: Horcrux hunting)

Marion Ros mros at xs4all.nl
Wed May 31 07:52:16 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 153187




> "juli17ptf" <juli17 at ...> wrote:
>> JKR said once that she couldn't identify Snape's patronus because it
>> would reveal too much. Some of us thought it might reveal Snape's
>> true loyalty. But what if instead it reveals Snape's ultimate *role*
>> as a snake-killer?  <snip>


If it 'reveals too much', logic woud suggest that Snape's patronus would 
definitely show which side he is on.
Since I'm firmly in the 'Snape's a White Hat' camp, my guess would be that 
his patronus is a phoenix, just like Dumbledore's.
It would make sense too. Those two have been joined at the hip, playing 
'good cop - bad cop' for *years* (really, Snape gliding billowy through the 
halls,with his slicked back hair like the Demon King from a Christmas 
Pantomime and Albus Dumbledore with his spangly robes, his sweets and his 
twinkle - they are laying it on quite *thick*, don't you think?) They are 
two sides of the same coin, so why wouldn't they have the same patronus? 

Marion






More information about the HPforGrownups archive