Nice vs. Good - Compassion

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 153191

> Carol responds:
> Or he could be pretending not to believe it because DE!Draco is in 
the
> class. (However, he's not pretending that he doesn't take cheek, 
even
> from celebrities or heroes!) 
<SNIP>

Alla:

Personally I thought that it was great that six books after that JKR 
totally mocked his taking points from Harry IMO by Slugghorn saying 
the 
same line that Snape did, the only difference being that he gave 
points to Harry.

To me, it spoke volumes that Snape was not testing any theories or 
had any underlying reasons for doing what he did. Just petty 
behaviour towards the child, IMO.

> Lolita responded:
<HUGE SNIP>
And killig sb who was your mentor and 
> > > friend, all for a higher cause (I believe that SS is DD's man) 
is 
> > > also very cowardly. These are just a few *cowardly things with 
no 
> > > risk involved* that I can think of without consulting all the 
> > > books. What a coward, indeed!
> > > 
> > > P.S. This *was* sarcasm, of course.


Alla:

Of course if one believes that Snape may not be DD!M, than his 
behaviour on the Tower becomes the very epithome of cowardice.

JMO,

Alla