Snape a vampire? (was Snape's Patronus)

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 160901

No, you are correc, Snape threads will never die....

Snape had the opportunity to guide Harry...he made the Malfoy 
decision...(bad idea) but he made the choice....and it never backfired 
upon him until HBP....Snapes big mistake....being a coward(after DD's 
protection) he never tried to save Harry only tried to find out 
harry's ultimate foe....

In COS...I think Snape with his friendship with Malfoy...and his 
animosity towards the weasleys....there may well have been some sort 
of conspiracy there....

And in POA...we get Harry in Hogsmeade...but did snape tell DD about 
this?

In GOF..just more animosity from snape...after he see's Harry 
surviving...I believe this is where he(snape) wavers for the first 
time..

OOP--where we learn snape is none to fond of Harry's dad, also, we 
learn snape is a occlumens...were we see snape physically harm Harry 
for the first time..

I would argue that snape is not a "TRUE" vamp...simply an EMOTIONAL 
VAMPIRE...(and don't most of us know this type)...

HBP-where Snape is actually able to teach Harry for the first time 
ever..

Also...if DD had been honest about Snape(which in his opinion he 
was/is)....or if DD had compelled Snape to be honest..( he would no 
longer be a DE and would have confessed what he knew...it would have 
been horrible)

I think DD knew snape through and through...and as for Harry and the 
TRIO...I think they know Snape trough and through and through..in 
GOF...we find the invalubilty of Hagrid, Dobby, and an outside house!

I think in HBP DD may have come to said realization....but didn't want 
to tell Harry..It's really important..Hence Mundungus was arrested...
(to show harrry that the MOM did make a realistic arrest.)
I think DD as he always does...left it to the individual in the 
end...he didn't...Snape wavered...Snape proved a great deal...DD would 
sacrifce for Harry...yet clearly...Snape...would not..Hence said 
arguement in the forrest between DD and Snape that Hagrid overheard...
I think, that after all these books...that snape has one chance and 
one chance alone...to make his patronus a stag...that is the only way 
he"ll be able to communicate with any of the marauders, harry or most 
of the order....and even then....shame on him for making a 
UV...although it was the only way he could have saved DD...it was also 
the only way he could not....really, all should have listened to 
harry...and harry should have had dobby follow malfory more closely..

DD