Just want to ask a question about HORCRUXES.....

Eddie harryp at stararcher.com
Fri Nov 3 16:16:56 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 160912

> Lantis:
> In book 2 (Chamber Of Secrets), just in case the soul encased in
> Riddle's Diary (which is we know a Horcrux) managed to "rise again"
> (when he sucks the life out of GINNY), what would happen??? I mean,
> what would happen to the REAL VOLDEMORT??? Would the VOLDEMORT who
> will "rise again" would be the same Voldemort or a different one? (A
> sixteen (or seventeen)-year old Voldemort?) Would that be possible? 
> 
> Is there a way we can ask this out to JK Rowling?

Eddie:
Really interesting question!  It opens up a lot of avenues of thought.

I suppose you can ask Rowling.  Her website (
http://www.jkrowling.com/textonly/en/faq_view.cfm?id=2 ) says, "Where
can I write to you? My publishers will forward letters."  But don't
expect an answer.  There are 6 Billion people on the planet and
5.999999999 billion (that's everybody except Jo herself) want to get a
direct answer from Rowling.

My speculation: There would be two Voldemort entities.  But the
entities!Voldemorts would seek each other out and rejoin.  It seems
logical that if someone is able to put a piece of their soul into a
Horcrux, there must be some way to get that piece safely out again and
to reintegrate it.  I speculate that since the soul was "torn" prior
to the creation of the Horcrux, the rejoining would never be perfect
again.

Eddie, who is not JKRowling, but is absolutely certain that the real
JKRowling reads this website in the hopes she can learn something
clever from my posts.  :-)






More information about the HPforGrownups archive