Hiding from Voldmort / Moral Relativism (was:Re: witches of the world...

[MercuryBlue]

No: HPFGUIDX 160956

> Madame Bones was a member
> (returning from the original incarnation), IIRC

Madam Bones was in the Order? Since when? She wasn't in the picture of 
the original Order that Mad-Eye showed Harry, certainly. This was 
after he'd seen her at the hearing, so I think Harry would have 
noticed it if she was there. Nor did we see her at Grimmauld Place at 
any point.

I suppose someone could make a case that not all the Order members 
came to Grimmauld or that Harry missed seeing a few of those that did, 
and that we didn't hear about Madam Bones being in that picture 
because Mad-Eye stopped naming people when he got to James and Lily, 
which would allow the possibility that Madam Bones was in the Order, 
but it wouldn't convince me.

MercuryBlue