Live again, Dumbledore!

Elizabeth Snape snapes_witch at yahoo.com
Mon Nov 6 06:02:41 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 161047

Alicia:
> I was really upset too, but then I remembered (just last night)
> that Dumbledore will live again! Well, in a way. If you remember,
> all the previous headmasters and headmistresses of Hogwarts have
> portraits in the headmaster/headmistress office! So no doubt
> Dumbledore will have one too! So maybe Harry will be able to talk
> to the portrait and get help that way! (My fingers are crossed!)
> :)

Snape's Witch:

Dumbledore's portrait has already appeared in the headmaster's
(headmistress's?) office but he appears to be sound asleep.  The poor dear does need his sleep, you know!


ivaldoo:
> I don't believe that Dumbledore is dead. It must be a ploy between
> Snape and Dumbledore to get closer to Voldemort places. Since the
> earlier chapter where Snape promise to Malfoy's mother & aunt, it
> is hard to believe that Snape could be easily swayed like that.
> Then, the moment where Snape "killed" Dumbledore, it is weird on
> how killing is done. It is actually Snape who sacrifced himself to
> become the "bad-betrayed person" in order to get closer to
> Voldemort, and ironically it is heroic.

Snape's Witch:

Like you, I believe Dumbledore and Snape had a plan to get Snape in
deeper with Voldie, they just were blindsided by the occurrence on
the Tower.

Unfortunately, DD is really, really dead.  If the portrait isn't
solid proof for you; JKR told us at the NYC reading in August that he was definitely dead and it was time for us to start working our way through the stages of grief -- especially denial.

Snape's Witch








More information about the HPforGrownups archive