[HPforGrownups] Re:Heir of Gyffindor (Re: Pettigrew was Potter's Secretkeeper)

[J]

No: HPFGUIDX 161193

Eddie wrote: 
2) If Harry was a Gryffindor heir, then possibly his mother Lily was,
which means Aunt Petunia would be, which means Dudley (!) would be a
Gryffindor heir.

Dantzel replies:
I don't agree with the possibility of Lily being a Griffindor heir. Muggleborn is Muggleborn. JKR has repeatedly debunked the idea of Petunia or Dudley having magic...
Nice idea though. :)
======================

Jeremiah:

NOOOOOO!!!! Dudly can never be that cool!!!! I forbid it! LOL

Ummm, I was thinking if it was on Jame's side.. with all the money and what-not. But I think someone mentioned that it JKR made a point about Dumbledore being the hier and not Harry. However, if the Potter family tree and the Dumbledore family tree were to cross somewhere... that would make it possible. We don't know how far back either family goes because they aren't of the "Most Noble House of Black" mentality. Much more relaxed that that kind of arrogance.

And Petunia would most definitely be less of a pucker-mouthed priss about the wizarding world of she were an hier of someone so famous. Infact, she' probably be cruel to Dudly for not being magical! What a twist that would be.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]