[HPforGrownups] Re:Heir of Gyffindor (Re: Pettigrew was Potter's Secretkeeper)

[Dantzel Withers]

No: HPFGUIDX 161205

> >>Eddie: 
>> 2) If Harry was a Gryffindor heir, then possibly his mother Lily was... << <snip>
 
> >>Dantzel:
>> I don't agree with the possibility of Lily being a Griffindor
heir. Muggleborn is Muggleborn. << <snip>

> >>Eddie:
>> Does "Muggle" mean that there is _ABSOLUTELY NO_ wizard blood in them? Couldn't Godric Gryffindor's blood run through muggle families, even those who have no magic? Meaning, Muggleborn people could still be Gryffindor's heirs. I'm not saying, nor did I mean to say, that Petunia or Dudley were "magical", only that they could be Gryffindor's heirs. <<

Dantzel:
I considered this in my reply, however, what would be the point of including this in what is already an extremely long list of questions to answer in book 7? I can't see it helping to resolve the plot if they were to be Gryffindor's heir, with no magic of their own. JKR has told us often that Dudley has no magic and neither does Aunt Petunia.

Just FYI Eddie, though I haven't posted often to show it, I almost always agree with your comments and arguments. It's just this one. :)

Dantzel, who feels quite sick of working today.