Who did Kreatcher talk to in OOTP?

Steve bboyminn at yahoo.com
Thu Nov 9 07:30:20 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 161314

---  "Hagrid" <aussie_lol at ...> wrote:
>
> aussie writes:
> 
> I... JKR clues that gave the impression Kreatcher went 
> to speak to someone.
> 
> ... (after) Mr Weasley's > ... Kreatcher would disappear,
> and have a different attitude when he returned.
> 
> When Harry checked to see if Sirius was in Grimauld Place,
> Kreatcher had bandages on his hands (Dobby-like injury 
> after disobeying his master).
> 
> any ideas? Has this been in discussions before?
> Aussie
>

bboyminn:


This has indeed been discussed, but it is also explained
to Harry by Dumbledore at their end of book discussion.

Near Christmas when Arthur Weasley is attacked, Sirius
ordered Kreacher 'OUT!', and Kreacher took that as 
meaning get out of the house. So, Kreacher went /out/ to 
the only /available/ member of the Black family that he 
respected which was Narcissa Black-Malfoy. From her, 
Kreacher's information reached Voldemort. 

Kreacher had been ordered not to reveal any information
about the Order, or what was happening in the Black House.
But Sirius, not taking Kreacher very seriously, negelected
to prevent Kreacher from revealing minor more indirect 
information, like  the fact that Harry and Sirius were 
close, and that Harry was very likely to come to Sirius's
aid regardless of the circumstances or danger. Voldemort 
used this minor, apparently insignificant information to 
lay at trap for Harry.

Again, Dumbledore explains it all near the end of the
book.

Steve/bboyminn






More information about the HPforGrownups archive