[HPforGrownups] Re: Harry is Not A Horcrux, But the Sword Is

[lil.magill at adelphia.net]

No: HPFGUIDX 161322

hpmyth:

I think that the sword appeared in the hat in the second book will be a Horcrux.

Marion here:

Sorry if I'm repeating anything others have said, but there's 
so much volume in this group, and I'm forced to skim some 
of the longer posts.  I don't thing the sword will be a horcrux 
-- too easy, and Dumbledore would have surely thought of it 
and destroyed it long ago.  As far as Harry - or Lily or any 
other living thing --being a horcrux, isn't it too risky?  If the 
person dies, V's soul would die with it.  Seems to me they've 
got to be inanimate objects.