snape turning good maybe? / Secret Keepers / Horcrux

[christphrmurray]

No: HPFGUIDX 161361

I think that Snape could turn on Voldemort if it came down to say
killing Harry.  He would turn because he hated James true, but he cared deeply for Lily, and both are there in Harry. That is why he wants to strangle Harry sometimes but never really hurts the boy. Because of Lily.

I also think Snape did turn good after James and Lily died but got cornered in HPB.  That spell made it so he either had to help Draco or die and most people, if they had to make that decision, would have done the same and probably against their will.  But Snape is going to be hunted big time and probably fighting his conscious in the next book.

And I have the idea that Dumbledore and Snape set it up due to the cursed hand, that was possibly killing Dumbledore with a slow and painful death.  It sounds like a curse that Voldemort would do to anyone who messed with his stuff.  This might be true but there is just as much evidence against it. Like Snape did kill.  Well, it still got him on the bad guy list near the top for now.

Okay, as far as the Secret Keeper thing: Harry was there. He might have to go in alone if it still works.  But I don't think it is because it was made for Lily and James.  If it was done before Harry was born, when they died so did the spell. That is how they found baby Harry in the house. Makes sense to me.

Harry being a horathingy: I think it is not possible because of the prophecy. One has to die so the other can keep going.  But Harry might not be a proper horcrux since he didn't die and that is why he stole some of Voldemorts' abilities.  Like parseltongue.

There is no real way to find out till the book comes out (hopefully this coming year on 7/7/07).  But we all know they won't tell anyone till then. And all the secrets before the new book helps build up the anticipation.

Well, have a good day.

chris murray