Chamber of Horcruxes

[Eddie]

No: HPFGUIDX 161363

> Carol responds:
> One other
> possibility, and I'm waiting to hear everyone jump on this idea as
> unlikely, is that he can perform Legilimency on memories and read
> Memory!Morfin's thoughts. Just a possibility I'm tossing out, not an
> interpretation I'm arguing for.

Eddie:
Interesting thought.  The problem I have with this is that it would
just make him too omniscient to be allowed (to borrow a phrase).  He
would be able to pensieve-dive into all those memories he seems to
have access to and know what just about everybody was thinking and/or
concealing: Tom Riddle as boy, young man working for B&B, as a
job-seeker for DADA; At the Death Eater trials; and, as you say, with
the Gaunts.

Following your hypothesis, I suppose pensieve!Voldemort would still be
a powerfully gifted occlumens, but more powerful than a real life
Dumbledore who could try again and again and again at his leisure?

Like I said, interesting thought.  But I'd need more persuading.

Eddie