Performer of fidelius charm
spookedook
spookedook at yahoo.co.uk
Wed Nov 15 17:32:20 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 161552
TinkTonks:
My problem is that on the JKR Website FAQ's JKR says that the status
of the secret remains the same if a SK dies (Which DD thought PP
had). So therefore wouldnt the best course of action for DD have
been to rebuild GH and have someone keep Harry there? Nobody could
reach him!
If your theories (Which I like very much by the way) are right I
dont understand why D would have chosen a life of misery for Harry!
Lynn:
DD believed Sirius to be the SK so as far as he was concerned, SB
would be in Azkaban blabbing to everyone where Harry was. PP
wouldn't have factored in since no one knew he was the SK except SB.
Tinktonks;
I see where your coming from but I dont see Azkaban as the have a
gossip in the execise yard kind of joint. More the solitary
confinment assylum kind of deal.
Plus I would imagine Dumbledore would have SB cast as a sinister sly
snide kinda guy. Knowledge is power - and he wouldn't be likely to
share his power with inmates.
Just my humble opinion!
Tinktonks
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive