Harry Potter WAS a Horcrux

[Clifford Vander Yacht]

No: HPFGUIDX 161599

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "dustin_pppr" <dustin_pppr at ...>
wrote:
<snip>
> Harry was a horcrux.  We have no other explanation for the connection
> between him and LV, and Dumbledore has specifically mentioned that
> there is a connection and the scar is part of it.  So, LV stored a
> part of his soul in HP, whether on purpose or by accident.
> 
> I said Harry WAS a horcrux, but I do not think he is one anymore.  My
> reason: Dumbledore's gleam of triumph at the end of GOF.  HP explains
> that LV used his (HP's) blood in the potion and that his mother's
> protection is gone, and HP notices a gleam of "something like triumph"
> in Dumbledore's eyes.
> <snip>

Cliff here:

The simple reason is that because LV became human again using Haryy's
blood, maybe DD thinks that LV is also no longer imortal. DD couldn't
identify all of the horcruxes and the triumph may mean that they don't
all have to be destroyed to kill LV. Speculation.