Sevens.
Jen Reese
stevejjen at earthlink.net
Sun Nov 19 21:38:52 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 161700
> > Ken says:
> > Well, perhaps that we have been introduced to the location of a
> > horcrux and the object it is within in every book?
Carol says:
> An interesting idea if we count the first "Horcrux" we're
> introduced to as Voldemort himself. (There are seven soul bits but
> only six Horcruxes, assuming that they've all been created.} So
> SS/PS introduces Voldemort, CoS gives us a Hogwarts Horcrux, GoF
> introduces Nagini, but HBP introduces two locations, the Gaunt
> hovel and the cave. That leaves three locations for the other four
> books. A good thought, but it doesn't quite work out (unless we
> don't get any new locations in Book 7).
Jen: A location in each book doesn't work out perfectly, no. Well,
except both the locket and the diary were taken over by someone else
and were out of Voldemort's control, so JKR might count Grimmauld
Place as the OOTP location (and the diary ended up where it belonged
so that would count). POA is the hardest to think of a location.
Hogsmeade connection? Shrieking Shack? We don't know of a
Voldermort connection to these places. He left his 'friends' at the
Hog's Head the night he requested a job at Hogwarts, but that was a
defeat for him. And it's a public place which isn't his pattern so
far.
Carol:
> So what other locations do we associate with Voldemort? I very much
> doubt that there's a Horcrux at Godric's Hollow, which he would
> associate with his defeat, and I can't think of any new Voldie
> locations introduced in OoP. (The locket Horcrux will be probably
> be in 12 GP, not a location associated with Voldie, who hid it or
> had Bella hide it in the cave.) And the Riddle House, introduced
> in GoF, probably hides Nagini.
Jen: Even if the orphange is still around it's a place Voldemort
detested. Borgin & Burkes gave him the opportunity to start
collecting treasures but the risk is high because Voldemort would
have had to enchant the Horcrux for people to pass over it and it's
a public place (not his pattern, again). The Room of Requirement is
a possibility, people have suggested the tiara. St. Mungos doesn't
seem likely as there's not a connection we know of.
What about the MOM? The DOM is not exactly a public place and
Voldemort would get a thrill out of hiding a Horcrux right under the
nose of the WW establishment. Plus he knows how to get into the DOM
without anyone knowing he's there. Which room though, and what
protections are on the Horcrux so no one can discover it? And if
the last Horcrux is in the DOM there's even more evidence the final
showdown will be there as well.
Jen R., wondering how many chapters will be devoted to the grand
finale.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive