A journey "into the thickets of wildest guesswork."

[vama_30595]

No: HPFGUIDX 161881

White_Wolf:
> One problem I can see with your theory is that why would Petunia
> inherit the house elf, instead of Harry.  We know Harry can inherit
> house elves, as shown by Kreacher.
>
>

vama replies:

I dont think that Petunia would inherit a house-elf. But even if she
wants to  then she would be able to because Harry can inherit house-
elves(Dobby, Kreacher- because of Sirius.)
Still I think it seems less likely for Petunia to have a house-elf
though her house is extremely neat and clean.Anyway.....