[HPforGrownups] Re: Ronald Weasley
Lana
unicornspride at centurytel.net
Fri Nov 24 20:26:26 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 161915
>Cassy wrote:
>Interesting theory. Somehow I never >heard it before. I
>agree that Ron will not flip side >willingly, but I
>believe Imperius is not the only option. >If Ron had to
>choose between lives of Ginny, or >Mione, or his
>parents, taken hostage by LV, and Harry >whom would he
>chose? Would he betray Harry to save >others he loves
>or sacrifies them?
>My, Melanie wrote:
>I doubt very seriously he would ever >really betray Harry. However, I do >wonder about Molly Weasley, and not >her giving up Harry but lets just say she >had an opportunity to give info. As >where Hermione is...I think she would >do it if she was told that her family >would then be spared.
Lana writes:
Now that is a dang good question.. Molly... Hmmm..
I can't see her giving anyone up, however, for the sake of her family, she might give up info. To Molly her family is the most important. Look how she reacted to the boggart.
I would have to say as a parent, it would be a natural choice to save your children even if it meant someone else would die.
However... Most adults would do what they could to protect all involved. I cannot say that I honestly think she could betray Harry, but I also do not think she would choose him over her own.
Lana
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive