Time turner theory

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 162001

> Carol responds:
> 
> Much as I like Magda's suggestion that it was Harry who saved the
> teenage Severus Snape from werewolf!Lupin, I just don't see how 
that's
> feasible, nor do I see Harry being motivated to save the future 
Death
> Eater/eavesdropper, HBP or no, especially since it was Snape who
> killed Dumbledore. If anything, he'd want James to let Severus 
die, in
> which case, the consequences would be much worse. Voldemort would
> never have been vaporized and there would be no Prophecy Boy to 
stop him.
<SNIP>

Alla:

Well, of course I agree - he would want James to let Snape die( then 
he would at least have **some** chance to grew up with mother and 
father, not with Dursleys. Not a guarantee of course, but a 
possibility if you ask me).

But despite that I can totally see poor Harry gritting his teeth and 
being mature enough and going back to save Snape precisely because 
that would be good for the WW.

Not that I think that Voldemort's dissappearance in any way, shape 
or form justifies the disgusting deed ( in my book of course) that 
Snape committed by telling prophecy to Voldemort, but of course 
unintended good for the wizards and witches came out of it, they got 
the decade of peace.

Too bad that Harry had to pay the highest price for that if you ask 
me.

Alla, who is only getting more disgusted with Snape telling Prophecy 
to Voldemort as the time goes by and hopes that he will pay before 
Harry forgives him.