What if Regulus is ALIVE?

[Rebecca Hillary]

No: HPFGUIDX 162041

Magpie:
> Since Regulus has already been introduced as dead in canon, it seems
> normal to just shoot down the Stubby is Regulus theory.

Funnily enough, due to my refusal to believe that Snape is evil, I'm
more inclined to believe that Regulus is also alive, is not a Death
Eater, but was the 'large, blonde Death Eater' who was following Snape
and Malfoy out of the castle at the end of HBP. Snape and Regulus are
taking Malfoy into hiding and Dumbledore's not dead! And I think that
it was Regulus who got the real horcrux, but not as long ago as we are
being led to believe.

Beci