Cohesion

rduran1216 rduran1216 at yahoo.com
Thu Nov 30 09:11:41 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 162184

I've been mulling over the situation at where Half-Blood Prince ends,
and it seems to me there's something seriously wrong, and/or there is
something Dumbledore didn't share with anyone (except maybe Snape)
regarding the horcruxes and how it is that he seems to know the
future.  The implied clues dictate that Dumbledore planned what
happened, but at the same time, it doesn't seem like anyone besides
Snape was in on it as well.  My biggest proof for this is the way
Dumbledore acts all year long, especially towards the Dursleys, and
the subtle lines laced throughout.  So my question is, let's assume
the opposite, that Snape really is an instrument of Voldemort's, how
can the story possibly be brought together, given that Rowling has
said no new major characters will be introduced?

rduran1216




More information about the HPforGrownups archive