[HPforGrownups] Re: A thought..

[Lana]

No: HPFGUIDX 162189




  Melanie wrote:
  >
  > I was reading the Prisoner of Azkaban for the 400th : ) time the 
  > other day and came across something I never gave much thought too 
  > before. In one of the last Chapter's Dumbledore told Harry he may 
  > one day be grateful he saved Wormtail's life.. He said once you save
  > a wizard's life, they tend never to forget that no matter how dark a 
  > wizard they may be... Could this be a omen for #7?? What is anyone 
  > else's view on this??

  >Rashi wrote:
  Cool. What an idea. My only response or comment is, >Dumbledore must be 
  wrong in this case. In addition to his deep devotion to >"you know 
  >who", he is far too much a weasel and a rat to give back >to Harry, 
  >even if Harry saved his very life.



  Lana writes:

  I am not sure that I completely agree with Rashi. I think this may come into play at the end or close to it.  You have to remember that Wormtail is on the winning side.  He will choose whatever will keep him alive and safe.  

  If there is a point where he feels his security with LV is compromised, he will change sides.  We know this.  He hid as a rat for 12 years.  He was scared of both sides.  He then went back to LV because he was scared of the dementors as well as Sirius and Lupin.

  So.. Keeping his past actions in mind, he may very well come to Harrys aid in the end.  Maybe in his warped brain as a tribute to James and Lily.  Maybe just in hopes of surviving.

  Lana


  . 
   

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]