Blood Protection/Dumbledore and Harry

[a_svirn]

No: HPFGUIDX 159000

>Cyril:
> 
> LV himself mentioned that he was ripped from his body, after his
> rebirthing. He never said his body was destroyed. 

a_svirn:
He never said that it got left behind either. Nor did anyone else. 
Which is strange, considering that it would have been the most 
obvious argument for those who believed that he left for good. And 
wouldn't it be more logical to use his own remains for his 
reincarnation? 

>Cyril:
> IMO, with Sirius, the picture is very different. Siring was not 
AK's,
> given the red light he was hit with, instead of green light. It is
> also not clear if it was the curse that killed him, or because he 
went
> behind the veil. The reason we do not have a body is because he 
passed
> through the veil - and given our little knowledge about that, we
> cannot equate it to what happened to LV.

a_svirn:
I don't equate it to what happened to Voldemort, I just point out 
that when a body is absent Rowling tend to use "gone" instead 
of "died".