DIARY was(Re: A new Voldemort/Harry Theory based on a challenge post. on HPFF)

[spookedook]

No: HPFGUIDX 159158

KathyO wrote:

Harry destroys Riddle's Diary. Later we learn the book is a Horcrux.
Keeping that point in mind, didn't Harry destroy the book rather
Easily? Think about the difficulties in the cave with the necklace?

Tinktonks:

I can see where you're coming from on this but personally I dont
think there was anything 'easy' about having your arm pierced by a
highly poisonous fang of a creature that can kill you without even
getting close.

I don't think its fair to say it was easy. The basilisk was even
described as 'Voldemort' beast. Any beast that LV associates would
have to be the most poisonous inescapable creature possible.
Therefore the potency of the poison very high - not suprising a
horcrux should succumb to this.

The entire situation in which the diarycrux was destroyed was totally
unpredictable and not entirely at Harry's will. I don't think that
makes it easy.

I have actually been wondering about this for a while now. Excuse me
if my paraphrasing is terrible but at the point doesn't it say
something along the lines of 'Harry picked up like the Basilisk fang
as hough he had always intended to do it'

Does this suggest to anyone that maybe HARRY didn't intend to do it,
someone else did. Like it wasn't his though at all.

I've been working on theory that you guys will probably rip to
shreds (But have fun doing it!!!!) but what if LV was intending to
create a horcrux with Harry but when the spell reversed he didn't
create his own horcrux - but Lily's?

Any takers?

Tinktonks