[HPforGrownups] Name of Book 7
Gina Ayars
flutterby4490 at sbcglobal.net
Sat Oct 7 18:12:38 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 159185
tomriddledarklord <tomriddledarklord at yahoo.com> wrote:
<snip> There are two kids dealing with prophecy - Harry and
Neville. <snip>
Here I take a wild guess that if Harry is used as a scapegoat for
Neville. I.e Neville is the son of Potters and Harry the son of
Longbottoms. <snip>
So he must have interchanged the kids so that the chosen one, i.e
Neville, be still safe and Harry could be made a scapegoat and also
fooling Voldemort and JKR has very cleverly put the Longbottoms
into a situation of insanity so there be no doubt to anyone save
Voldemort but including the readers. <snip>
Recall Dumbledore says Voldemort has brought this chaos against
him by transferring his powers to Harry who is not the chosen one.
Dumbledore always says that Voldemort is fool enough to bring this
present situation unnecessarily. Which supports my point that Albus
is talking with double meaning. <snip>
Gina:
Well, except for one thing, Harry looks like his father. He is
obviously a POTTER. However, Neville may have been the chosen
one originally but Voldemort is the one that created the situation
with Harry, by choosing of the two, Harry. So there could indeed
be a plot twist involving Neville, but I doubt that it is that
Harry is a Longbottom, and Neville a Potter.
Gina
I am new btw, HI :)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive