What about this theory?

jdl3811220 jlenox2004 at yahoo.com
Mon Oct 9 03:30:42 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 159254

As I stated before in a previous post: In HBP (just before Snape
comes out and kills Dumbledore) Dumbledore tells Draco that
Voldemort can't kill Draco if Draco is already dead, meaning
Voldemort would 'think' he was dead. Then he tells Draco that they
(the Order) could hide Draco and his family so thoroughly that they
could never be found.

This gives me a tiny bit of doubt that the Potters, Dumbledore and
the whole dang lot of them are really really gone. All the ones that
supposedly gave their lives to the cause are "dead" but are they
REALLY? HMMMM

It's just a theory I'm kicking around. I really think that the
Potters and Dumbledore ARE gone. And, like Dumbledore has told Harry
time and time again, there is no spell that can reawaken the dead.
But why would JK have Dumbledore say that to Draco unless it will
have some significance in the 7th book?

I also looked back at a previous post where someone suggested that
Neville is the acutal Chosen One. I don't believe that. Dumbledore
tells Harry that it is obvious that it IS him (Harry)in book 5.

BUT look at that theory from this angle - Neville would have powers
the Dark Lords knows not!! HMMM. Neville would be the secret weapon,
the one to do Voldemort in! Now THAT would be cool, and downright
sneaky of JK. Her books do have twists and turns:)


"jdl3811220"








More information about the HPforGrownups archive